38


May 2000

Journal of Family Medicine

An overview of Obstetric and Gynaecology (vol 11)

(Defining the protocols for family physicians by family physicians with the help of experts).

_____________________________________________________

Expert.

Prof Dr Farrukh Zaman

MBBS, FCPS.

Professor of Obstetrics and Gynaecology.Authority on Infertility disorders.

Post Graduate Medical Institute ,Services Hospital

From 6pm to 10 pm,Hamid Latif Hospital,Ferozpur Road,near Qazzafi Stadium

Tel nos,5862623,5882656,,Mobile:0300 441601.
________________________________________________________________________


Opportunities to improve your skills!

Prof Farrukh has very kindly and generously offered to provide training to any doctor in Gyn/Obs.All collaegues especially ladies should avail this oppurtunity.Please contact Dr Saadia or Dr Mehboob Ashraf in this regard.

Thank you Prof Furrukh!

We have been taxing your patience, time, energy and capacity to put up with elementary stuff. Great threshhold there! During last interview, we just kept on asking and asking even when you were so tired and short of time. Not only this, you have encouraged us to the degree that we may be little hyperinflated. Our hats off to you Sir! Valuable experience!
Chief Editor: Dr Saleem Akhtar Rana


This issue printed with the courtesy of

Premarin
Conjugated Estrogens.

Having 3500 pupblications and 55 years of experience
Wyeth/lederle.

Contents.

Subject Page no

Section by Dr Sa’adia Bakhtiar.

Section by Dr Liaqat Ali ch.

Section by Dr Mehboob Ashraf& Dr Sa’adia Bakhtiar on Contraception

Internet Section

Board of Management

Chair man: Dr Fazal Mehmood Uppal Tel no: 217067

Finances: Dr Mohammad Akram Awan.Tel no 215215.

Pakistan Society of Family Physicians.

352 E Satellite Town Gujranwala, e mail: drsar@brain.net.pk

Editorial:

Do we know enough?

Ask any doctor, does he know enough about contraceptive methods? Most probable answer will be! Yes what is the problem? What is so difficult?

Ask yourself following questions. You will soon know where you stand. (Editor)

When will family physicians take up their place in managing Obs/Gyn problems in spite of all limitations? Why to complain about patients always and never to take audit of our attitudes?

Why patients are going to quack lady nurses? How and when we are going to tell them and make them believe that MBBS doctor is anyway in much better position to deliver good health care then quacks.

Lumps in the breast are another topic where we the family physicians can contribute a lot if we follow the proper protocol. What is so difficult about FNA? Why can’t we do it in our clinics? If PSFP has some training programm for this simple procedure, how many of us will attend? And then adopt it in our practice?

Dr Saleem Akhtar Rana.

Panel Interview of

Prof. Dr. Farrukh Zaman

MBBS, FCPS


Professor of Obstetrics and Gynaecology

Postgraduate Medical Institute, Services Hospital, Lahore.

(Following text has been prepared from the answers given to the questions by the panel members. Panel consisted of Dr Saadia Bakhtiar, coordinator for this issue, and Dr Mehboob Ashraf, Dr Liaqat Ali Chaudhry and Dr Saleem Akhtar Rana)

Reproductive Health.

Definition: Care of female gender starting right from female foetus upto the grave. Application of this concept is essential to alleviate all cruelities meted out to women in all fields such as female fetocide.

Background: It is a relatively recent term. Uplift of Society is not possible untill women are fully developed, given equal status in all matters, and are properly educated. They should be economically independent. All human rights must be implemented fully and forcefully as regards women in any society. Prejudices against them should be eliminated. These concerns were raised and policies adopted in very high profile conferences in Cairo in 1994 and later in Beijing.

Contrception use rate increases when literacy rate and income goes up. In Siri Lanka literacy rate is 98 % and number of children is 2.8/women. In India this is 3.4,in Pakistan it is 5.4.Infant and maternal mortality rates also improve with improvements in income, education and granting of more and more rights. Awareness about these things has to be created not only in ladies but in males also.

Expenditure on such essential sector is appauling low. One week’s expenditure on armaments worldwide is more than what is being spent on contraception in whole of the world.

Role of Family Physicians:

They should lead the crusade

Sexually Transmitted Diseases, STDs:

Prolapse of Uterus.

Vaginal Discharge.

Urinary Incontinence

Mainly of 3 types. Urge, Stress and Detrusor instability.

Abortions

Diagnosis.Ultrasound examination is single most important investigation to diagnose the status.

At 6 weeks foetal pole should be visible. As long as it is visible at this time abortion should be labelled as threatened only. At 7-week gestation cardiac activity should be seen. If in doubt USG can be repeated after another one week. Again as long as cardiac activity is visible, abortion is not there.Urine pregnancy test can also be of help to diagnose pregnancy.

Repeated Abortions.

Some figures. In the same patient

Chance of first abortion = 5 %

// // Second abortion = 20 %

// Third abortion = 23-25 %

// Fourth abortion =30 %

So in the same patient even after 4 abortions chances of normal pregnancy are still 60-70 %.

Investigations.

Investigations like CBC, ESR, Urine, Blood Sugar, USG are in order.

Proper history should be taken. Complete pelvic examination by gynaecologist is essential.

Following investigations may be ordered for antithrombophilic syndrome.

Chances of normal pregnancy are only 10 %. With use of low dosage aspirin this rises to 40 %. Still further it can go upto 70 % with low molecular wieght heparin.

Karyotyping can be ordered from AFIP Rawalpindi, if patient can afford after 3rd abortion.

Recurrent U T I

A true midstream sample can really reduce many pus cell counts to normal.

If it is still 15-20 then urixin, Cefspan and Augmentin can be used after ordering for culture & sensitivity.These are safe in pregnancy also.

Investigations to rule out urological malformations and persistent pathology should be ordered in all difficult to manage cases.

Infertility

Causes: Male factors = 40 %

Female factors = 40 %

Both factors = 20 %

Time for investigations:

If there is no apparent abnormality in history, and couple is living together and having norml intercourse, wait for one year before there is any need for specific investigations.

Investigations.



Section by Dr Saadia Bakhtiar

Gynaecologist DHQ Hospital Gujranwala.

High-risk pregnancies. Vigilance needed by family physicians.


Firs term.1-13 weeks.


Ectopic Pregnancy.


To suspect it following features may be present in addition to abdominal pain.

If ruptured then along with signs and symptoms of acute abdomen

Ultrasound clinches the diagnosis.

Abortions.


Molar pregnancy


Hyperemesis Gravidarum.

(Management in vol 1)

U T I


2nd Term.14-26 weeks.

Bleeding P/V.

It should be dealt as abortion. Ultrasound examination for placental localization.

Polyhydramnias.

Oligohydramnias.

Patient complains of absent or sluggish foetal movements even at 22 weeks.

Ultrasound should be done for foetal well being, amount of liquor, and anomalies.

Multiple pregnancy.

Excessive enlargement of abdomen.

Ultrasound as early as possible.

Patient needs food supplements and calcium iron etc.

3rd Term, 27 – 40 weeks.

Eclampsia:

Discussed somewhere else.

APH

Any vaginal bleeding after 28 weeks.


Abruptio Placentae.From normally situated placenta. Has following features.

Placenta Praevia. (Low lying Placenta


Intra Uterine Demise.

Premature Labour.

___________________________________________________________

Pregnancy in the presence of medical problems.

Tuberculosis.

Jaundice in pregnancy

Same treatment as in non-pregnant ladies.

Pregnancy & DM

Only and only insulin should be given.

Pregnancy and heart problems.

Patient should be under care of heart specialist.

Indications for termination of Pregnancy

Following diseases, when present in an advanced stage and continuation of pregnancy has risk of worsening of these to the extent of endangering the life of mother, demand therapeutic abortions.

  1. Some heart diseases

  2. Severe hypertension.

  3. Malignant diseases: patient on chemotherapy.

  4. Severe Renal diseases.

  5. Severe respiratory disorders.

  6. Foetal anomalies.

  7. History of births of abnormal babies.

Important Emergencies in Obstetrics and Gynaecology.
Shock may be the setting in which patient presents. It can be present in many of the following conditions.

Obstetrics.

  1. Labour

  2. Premature Labour

  3. APH

  4. PPH and retained placenta.

  5. Eclampsia

  6. Ruptured Uterus.

  7. Peurperal Sepsis.

Gynaecology.

  1. Abortion.

  2. Ectopic Pregnancy

  3. Induced septic abortions.

  4. Perforated Uterus.

  5. Torsion of Ovarian cysts.

  6. Injuries.

Shock

Followings are the common causes.

  1. Bleeding P/V.in



  1. Ectopic.

  2. Dehydration

  3. Ruptured Uterus.

  4. Uterine Perforation.

  5. Less common causes like Pulmonry embolism, Amniotic embolism, Acute inversion of Uterus.

The physician of first contact must treat shock. Same common protocol.

Ectopic Pregnancy.Details in other sections.

.

Dehydration

Following may be the causes.

Ruptured Uterus.

Eclampsia

Following protocol.

Torsion of Ovarian Cyst.

Peurperal Sepsis.

If cause is located obviously management should be accordingly.

If no cause can be localized then PUO should be the diagnosis.

Vaginal Discharge.


Vaginal discharge can be

Pathological discharge can be

Characteristics of Normal vaginal discharge.

Leucorrhoea

Normal discharge sometimes becomes excessive. Continuos pouring makes patient uncomfortable. It excoriates vulva sometimes and may cause soreness. Anyone of the following causes can be present.

Pathological discharge

Inflammatory Discharge

Inter-course should be avoided for a week or condomes should be used for this period to avoid cross infections and reinfections. It can be

Even if examination is not possible history can suggest lot of diagnostic features.

Trichomonal Discharge.

Frothy, Foul smelling, and greenish yellow in colour, Itchy in nature, and it exaggerates after periods.

Monilial discharge.

White, Thick, curdy, no smell and itchy. Amount is maximum before menses. It is more common during pregnancy and in those patients who are on oral contraceptives, steroid immunosuppressents and antibiotics.

Bacterial discharge.

Malignant discharge.

Pelvic Inflammatory Disease.

Inflammatory disease of pelvis which can involve one or more reproductive organs and can be acute or chronic. Following types can be labelled.

  1. Acute Salpingitis to Peritonitis.

  2. Recurrent or chronic pelvic infections.

  3. Pelvic Abcess

  4. Tubo ovarian abcess.

  5. Postoperative pelvic infections.

  6. Pelvic tuberculosis.

Acute Salpingitis.Peritonitis.

Infections may start from vaginitis and if neglected ascend upward causing cervicitis, parametritis and peritonitis and oophoritis. Infections may spread from peritoneal cavity to tubes and downward. These may follow abortions or deliveries.

Essentials of Diagnosis.

Lower abdominal and pelvic pain following or at the onset of menses, along with vaginal discharge, dysmenorrhoea, Dyspareunea.Lower abdominal, Uterine, adnexal or cervical tenderness on movement. In addition one or more of following features may be present.


Differential Diagnosis.

Acute salpingitis must be differentiated from

Treatment

Complications.

Pelvic Tuberculosis.

Diagnostic features.

Low Backache

Since incidence of low backache is more in females, it is presumed that causes lie in genitalia. But the actual reason is weak musculature and insufficient ligamentous support in females along with stresses of pregnancy and coital positions.

Cuases in genital track.

Pain is diffuse and bilateral in distribution and below the level of L4.

  1. P I D (Especially Ch Cervicits): Accompanies vaginal discharge, pain lower abdomen, Dyspareunia, Severe dysmenrrhoea. History of abortion or recent delivery or peurperal sepsis may be present.

  2. Prolapse and retroversion: This is always relieved when patient lies down. Pain is dragging in nature.

  3. Tumours: A large abdominal tumour, ovarian masses, Endometriosis involving uterosacral ligaments.

  4. Pregnancy: Due to lordosis.

  5. Premenstrual tension: or other causes of pelvic congesion

  6. Gynaecological operations. Due to prolonged lithotomy positions, post op lying in sagging bed or prolonged lying on flat table.

Extra Genital causes.

  1. Obesity: Obviously weight reduction and excercises are primary tools.

  2. Grand multiparity and menopause: Ca supplementation with vit D & H R T and excercise.

  3. Bad postures

  4. Pendulous abdomen: Changes the centre of gravity and puts extra burden on back muscles.

  5. Bone and Joint lesions: Needs investigations.

  6. Diseases of Kidney and Ureters :

  7. Psychological Causes:

Brief Review of Problems of Breast.

Rule of Thumb:

Lump in the breast is the commonest finding and greatest source of tension. Nowadays rule of thumb is that no matter how benign and innocent looking lump is, it must be subjected to fine needle aspiration (FNA)

Further management is as follows.

All masses FNA (A) Cystic Mass (B) Solid Mass.

Findings 1) Clear Fluid 2) Residual Mass or thickening 3) Bloody Fluid

Follow up at 3 months

Excisional Biopsy Excisional biopsy

Cytologic preparation.

Malignancy Benign inconclusive

Treatment. Repeat FNA at 3 months Open surgical biopsy.

This scheme is simple one. If on aspiration there is fluid and this fluid clears on aspiration. All it needs to be done is to do aspiration again at 3 month. All other conditions require cytological examination whether tissue obtained on aspiration or on excisional biopsy.


Common Conditions.

  1. Fibrocystic changes.

B Fibroadenoma.


C CA Breast.

Single non-tender firm to hard mass with ill-defined margins and mammographic abnormalities.

Skin or nipple ulcerates axillary lymphadenopathy, redness, oedema, pain, and fixation of mass to skin or chest wall.

Ulceration, supraclavicular lymphadenopathy, edema of arm, Metastasis to bone, lung, liver, brain etc.

Peurperal Disorders.

Painful condition, usually at 3rd day onwards, especially when baby is unable to empty the breast. Enlarged breast tissue may b e palpable in axilla. Express the milk manually. Pump can damage the ducts. Hot fomentation, sedation, analgesics, adequate support to breast can be quite helpful. After each feed breast should be emptied.








Some Commercial Antifungal preparations.

Name How to use Total cost.


Vaginal Tablets.



Vaginal Antifungal Creams.


Antibacterial local applications.

Some commercial HRT preparations

Name Contents How to Use. Total monthly cost.



(O.D, from 5th to 25th day, Always gap of 7days.Then start new pack.)


Start from orange, proceed towards yellow. No gap

(More suitable for vasomotor symptoms)


One daily no gap RS 250

(Should be started one year after menopause.)

Kliogest One daily for 10 days from 15th to 25th day. Rs 75

Section by Dr Liaqat Ali Chaudhry

A family physician.



Adolescent Gynaecology.



Puberty and Menarche.

During infancy and childhood, the hypothalamus is inhibited from producing gonadotrophin releasing factors by the small amount of steroids secreted by the infantile ovaries.

Puberty is initiated by the maturation of the hypothalamus. It depends upon a complex interaction of hypothalamus, pitutary ovarian axis and environmental & genetic factors.

Typical sequence of events of Puberty includes Thelarche, Adrenarche, and Growth sprut, Menarche.

Thelarche.

First sign of a breast bud detected between 9 –11 yrs. It indicates release of endogenous estrogen by the ovary and points to the presence of pitutary gonadotrophins. Estrogen induces vaginal changes, ph becomes acidic and suitable for Doderlein’s bacilli.

Adrenarche

Pubic hair between 11 and 12 yrs indicates that the ACTH adrenal androgenic axis is intact and functional. Axillary hair appears after the completion of growth of pubic hair. Some females never develop axillary hair.

Growth Spurt.

At age of 12 an additional increment of 5 cms /year

Menarche.

It occurs when growth rate decelrates and breast development is almost complete. Early menstrual cycles are usually anovulatory and this period of adolescence sterility lasts 12-18 months after menarche.

Relationship between skeletal maturity and sexual maturation.

In the presence of sex hormones bone age progresses beyond 13 yrs leading to complete fusion of all epiphyses of hand bones. In the absence of sex hormones the bone age of hand and wrist remains at about 13 yrs.

Evaluation of Delayed Menarche.

Family physician has the capability to evaluate the vast majority of patients who depart from the normal timetable for sexual and somatic growth. Physiological delay, anatomic abnormalities and primary ovarian failure still comprise the largest number of patients with menarchal delay. Late adrenarche may be present in the family history but it does not eliminate the possibility of serious organic pathology.

For initial evaluation following basic studies are mandatory.

Breast Problems in Adolescence.

Serum prolactin levels and lateral X-ray of Skull are mandatory.

Vulvovaginitis.

Preadolescent age

Adolescent age.

Dysmenorrhoea.Symptoms include cramps in lower abdomen and back. Headache, nausea, vomiting, tension, irritability and depression. Prostaglandins cause contractions of smooth muscles.



Section written by Dr Saadia Bakhtiar and Dr Mehboob Ashraf.

Contraception

Different Categories of patients. First choice for them.

At the end of this chapter 7 possible categories have been defined with specific needs. Method of choice for each has been defined.

Three Cardinal principals.

.

When to start contraception.

First pregnancy should be ruled out. The best time in this regard is just starting all measures immediately after menses or during menses. This will ensure that there is no pregnancy.

Intrauterine Contraceptive Device I U C D.

I U D causes local sterile inflammatory reaction. This releases endothelial leukocytes. These are toxic to all cells including sperms and blastocyst. Addition of copper increases the capacity for inflammatory reaction. Medicated I U D contain progesteron which makes implantation difficult. It also changes the character of mucus in cervix.

It can not be advised if following situations are present.

Hormonal preparations

Checklist for Hormonal methods.

If answer is NO to all-following questions then hormonal methods can be started rightaway. Otherwise further assessment is required.

Contraceptive Pills.

Combination pills (COC)
Contain estrogens and low doses of progestogens. These may be high dose or low doses.
High dose: Ovral.Eugynon, Low dose: Microgynon.Nordette.
These are taken for 21 days with placebo tab for another 7 days to make the pack of 28 tabs.

Progestin only pills (POP): Microlut, Micronox, and Ovrette.

Sequential pills.

*For 1st two weeks of first time use.
*For rest of the cycle when she misses tablest on two consective days. If she misses on one day only, she should take two tabletes next day and complete the pack as usual.
*For rest of the cycle if She had diarrhoea or vomitting.
*When she stops taking the pills for any side effect.
*If she needs any protection against STDs.

Common Side effects.

Contraceptive Injections.

These contain progesterone, which inhibits hypothalamus-pitutary-Ovarian axis. It also affects the endometrium and cervical mucus. Two kinds of injections.

Depoprovera: Medroxyprogesterone 150 mgs.
Given every 3 months. Deep intramuscular. Failure rates 1%.

Noristerat (Not-En): Norethistrone 200 mgs. Given every 2 months. Deep intramuscular.

Side effects of contraceptive injections and their management.

Emergency /Post Coital Contraception.

Morning after pills can be used within 72 hours, although withen 24 hours is preferable. High dose steroids disrupt endometrium and render it difficult for implantation. Following tablets can be used.

Take 4 COCs of low dose, e.g, nova, nordette, and feminol. Repeat 4 tabs 12 hours later. Or 2 tabs of high dose (ovral) can be used, to be repeated 12 hours later.

Tab Postinor: one tablet withen one hour of intercourse. If there is another intercourse withen 3 hours then one more tablets should be taken. No more than 4 tabs can be taken in one month.

Laevonorgesterol implants. (Nor plants.)

This is long acting, reversible and affective birth control device. Six flexible silicon rubber implants, containing laevonorgesterol can be implanted under the skin on forearm. Small amounts of progesteron are released after regular intervals for 5 years. Main side effects are menstrual irregularities, which tend to settle in few months. Mode of action, side effects profile and their management is similar to injections.

Check list for Permanent Sterlization (Vasectomy, Tubal Occlusion)

Contraception in-patients with gynaecological problems.

All patients with any kind of gynaecological problem, who wish to be on contraception, need a thorough pelvic examination. Management should be obviously according to the findings. Following guidelines are for those patients whose examination is normal.

Contraception In patients with medical problem.

Patients with chronic medical problems should calculate the risks of pregnancy, contrception and sterlization. Doctor should help to focus the issues and provide complete information.

Different categories of patients.

Category: Future planning first other methods
of family choice

  1. Newly weds 6-12 months period Oral COCs Condoms

  2. Couples with planning some I U D COCs, Injecs-
    1-2 children interval condoms.

  3. Couples with no more planning Permanent I U D, COCs
    complete families. of children Methods

  4. Lactating mothers undefined I U D and inj condoms.
    (If more than 6 weeks post partum)

  5. Emergency Contraception.6) Patients with Gynaecological problems 7) Patients with medical problems. Management of these described above.

Internet Section. Debate on Male menopause is included to complete this topic of decline in sex hormones levels with age.
Section on HRT to relieve specific symptoms of Menopause, use of HRT is noncontroversial. Controversy is only about its prophylactic use for osteoporosis, risk for heart diseases and other problems of aging. This Internet section is ment to update our readers on this controversy.

For The male menopause


Duncan C Gould, consultant, Richard Petty, medical director.

The WellMan Clinic, 32 Weymouth Street, London W1N 3FA

It is not inevitability but may occur mainly in middle aged and elderly men when testosterone production and plasma concentrations fall. There seems to be a threshold plasma concentration below which symptoms may become apparent. Testosterone concentrations found to be critical for sexual functioning in men lie around 10.4 nmol/l (300 ng/dl), though there is variation between individuals. While some have found that differences in plasma testosterone concentrations within the normal range in young healthy men do not correlate with differences in sexual activity and interest, others have shown that differences in the concentrations of the potent metabolite, dihydrotestosterone, do.

An abnormally low concentration of testosterone (hypotestosteronaemia) may occur because of testicular dysfunction (primary hypogonadism) or hypothalamic-pituitary dysfunction (secondary hypogonadism) and may be congenital or acquired.

Endocrinology

In the ageing man reduction in testosterone concentration is due mainly to a decline in Leydig cell mass in the testicles or a dysfunction in hypothalamic-pituitary homeostatic control, or both, leading to abnormally low secretion of luteinising hormone with resultant low testosterone production.Mirroring this decline in plasma testosterone concentration is an age-associated increase in plasma concentration of sex hormone binding globulin, resulting in a more pronounced decline in the active or bioavailable testosterone moiety. Concentrations of bioavailable testosterone decrease by as much as 50% between the ages of 25 and 75 years, and it has been proposed that with respect to bioavailable concentrations as many as 50% of men over the age of 50 re hypotestosteronaemic when compared with peak early morning concentrations in young men. With age there is a loss of hypothalamopituitary circadian rhythm, which may result in exaggerated falls in plasma testosterone concentrations by evening.

Symptoms encountered in the male climacteric syndrome

Effects of hypotestosteronaemia

A quantitative definition of hypotestosteronaemia has generally been accepted as 11 nmol/l (320 ng/dl) as only 1% of healthy men aged 20-40 will have a concentration below this limit. Development of hypotestosteronaemia may be related to heredity as 60% of the variability of testosterone concentrations and 30% of sex hormone binding globulin may be due to genetic factors. A history of orchitis, testicular trauma, or other pathology may be contributory.The presence of obesity is associated with lower concentrations of bioavailable testosterone, and insulin concentrations have been found to be indirectly correlated with sex hormone binding globulin and testosterone concentrations. With respect to lifestyle, excess intake of alcohol and physical and psychological stress are all associated with lowered testosterone concentrations.

Affective symptoms have long been associated with hypotestosteronaemia: depressed mood is significantly correlated with low concentrations of bioavailable testosterone in older men. Some longitudinal uncontrolled studies of hypotestosteronaemic men have shown that symptoms of depression, anger, irritability, sadness, nervousness, friendliness, sense of wellbeing, and energy levels significantly improved with androgen treatment. There is evidence for mood disturbance being linked to hypotestosteronaemia and for testosterone replacement therapy being beneficial, but placebo-controlled trials are needed to confirm these issues. Fatigue may occur with hypotestosteronaemia. Profound hypotestosteronaemia in younger men results in accelerated bone loss and osteoporosis. In older men bioavailable testosterone concentrations are positively correlated with bone mineral density at the radius, spine, and hip,and men with hypotestosteronaemia have been reported to be at increased risk of hip fracture.

Investigations and treatment

Investigations should include assessments of concentrations of plasma gonadotrophin, prolactin, and sex hormone binding globulin and early morning concentrations of testosterone. Men with hypotestosteronaemia with unequivocal signs and symptoms of androgen deficiency, and when reversible causes of testosterone deficiency and contraindications have been excluded, should be offered treatment with testosterone replacement therapy in line with the current WHO

Against The concept of Male Menopause.

Howard S Jacobs, emeritus professor of reproductive endocrinology

Royal Free and University College School of Medicine,Middlesex Hospital, London W1N 8AA

The normal menopause the final cessation of menstruation is caused by primary ovarian failure. The oestrogen deficiency that often causes vasomotor instability (flushing and sweating attacks), genital atrophy (vaginal dryness and discomfort), and bladder irritability, together with difficulties in cognition and loss of a general feeling of wellbeing. This climacteric syndrome, readily reversible by oestrogen treatment, is obviously sex specific.

In thinking about this we do well to consider how many of the changes in men as they pass from middle to old age should be attributed to the passage of years and how many to a decline in hormone concentrations. It is easy to see the attraction of an endocrine explanation because it raises the possibility of hormone treatment for symptoms that occur at this time of life.Careful review of the literature is at best suggestive. Firstly, what are the hormonal changes that occur in ageing men? Certainly gonadal function wanes: by the age of 80 years.Serum total testosterone concentrations have fallen to about 75% and free testosterone concentrations to about 50% of what they were at the age of 20. The fall of free testosterone (that is, of the fraction that is biologically available to the tissues) is amplified by a difficult to explain but regularly observed increase in concentrations of the sex hormone binding globulin. The fall in testosterone production is partly caused by testicular failure and partly by changes in pituitary gonadotrophin secretion. The key difference from the menopause, however, is the gradual nature of the change in men compared with the precipitate fall of oestrogen concentration in women.

Secondly, what are the biological changes that can be related to these endocrine alterations? So far as sexual activity is concerned the role of testosterone in elderly men is still not well defined. Circulating concentrations of testosterone in older men are usually well above those needed for a normal sexual response, although the proportion of men complaining of erectile dysfunction rises dramatically with age, such that 50% of men between the ages of 50 and 70 years complain of impotence. As many as 80% of cases of erectile dysfunction are now thought to have a medical cause, such as diabetes mellitus, cardiovascular disease (especially angina and after myocardial infarction), neurological disorders (multiple sclerosis and spinal injury), pelvic surgery (prostatectomy), and trauma. Indeed some have suggested that the development of erectile dysfunction should be regarded as sentinel of disease and constitute an indication for careful medical assessment.

Recent work, reviewed elsewhere, has shown that what ultimately determines potency is the ability of muscles in the walls of the artery supplying the penis to relax and so permit engorgement to occur. Nitric oxide released from parasympathetic nerve endings in response to sexual stimulation causes guanylate cyclase to produce cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cyclic GMP), which relaxes arterial smooth muscle. Cyclic GMP is metabolised by a specific phosphodiesterase. Sildenafil citrate (Viagra) inhibits this enzyme, prolongs arterial relaxation, and so enhances erection. As far as impotence in the older man is concerned, unless hypogonadism can be clearly shown, treatment with sildenafil citrate (with appropriate warnings about cardiovascular risks and drug interactions with nitrites) is likely to be safer and more efficacious than injections of testosterone esters.

To conclude, I really do not find the analogy of the female menopause helpful in understanding or trying to manage the problems of senescence in men. Moreover, the endocrinology of ageing is much broader than that the term suggests. As Lamberts, van den Beld, and van der Lely have pointed out, while the fragility of elderly people might be related to a gonadopause, an adrenopause (the age related fall of dehydroepiandrosterone sulphate concentrations), or a somatopause (the decline in secretion of growth hormone and insulin like growth factor), actually in old people the commonest endocrine disorders are diabetes mellitus and hypothyroidism. These conditions are definitely treatable.



Hormone replacement therapy

Kay-Tee Khaw, Professor of clinical gerontology.

Clinical Gerontology Unit, University of Cambridge, Addenbrooke's Hospital,

Cambridge CB2 2QQ

(Appeared as editorial in BMJ 1998; 316:1842-44, 20 June)

Risk-benefit relation differs between populations and individuals

Hormone replacement therapy is increasingly advocated not just for short-term treatment of menopausal symptoms but as long term prophylactic therapy against heart disease, osteoporosis, and even Alzheimer's disease, as the solution to many of the problems of ageing women. Should universal hormone replacement therapy be recommended in asymptomatic healthy postmenopausal women?

Many clinicians now take it as established that postmenopausal hormone therapy protects against coronary heart disease in women. However, this is not based on data from randomised trials with coronary end points.

Nevertheless, oestrogen has biological actions that could plausibly explain cardioprotective effects. The PEPI trial has clearly shown that exogenous oestrogen administration in women raises high-density lipoprotein cholesterol, lowers low-density lipoprotein cholesterol, and decreases fibrinogen concentrations. Other studies indicate that oestrogens can have antioxidant effects, lower homocysteine concentrations, act as calcium channel blockers, alter vascular reactivity, and, more variably, improve glucose tolerance. The demonstrable effect on lipids, which are the strongest coronary risk factors, and the consistent strong findings for coronary heart disease in observational studies indicate a real protective effect of oestrogens, though perhaps not as great as the halving of risk observed.

In contrast, the evidence for stroke is much more equivocal. Postmenopausal hormone therapy had no effect on blood pressure in the PEPI trial, and observational studies indicate both increased as well as decreased stroke risks in hormone users.Nevertheless, hormone replacement therapy is also widely accepted to be protective for osteoporosis.and possibly for Alzheimer's disease, as well as for a variety of other menopause related conditions such as urinary symptoms and depression so why are there still reservations about universal prescription?

The concerns are over possible adverse effects and the overall risk-benefit balance of long term therapy in healthy women.The observed cardioprotective effect of oestrogen appears to be related to current use and diminishes after stopping. Thus, continued use is required for cardioprotection. While oestrogens undoubtedly increase bone density in women in trials, observational studies on fracture risk suggest that the protective effect be related to duration of use; as with cardiovascular disease, benefits appear to diminish rapidly after cessation. Weiss reported that women have to use oestrogens for at least five years before a protective effect on hip fractures is observed. Unfortunately, oestrogen use increases the risk of both